When We First Met

Movie Cast · 2018

Using a magical photo booth that sends him back in time, Noah relives the night he met Avery over and over, trying to persuade her to fall for him.

Autographs for sale 🤍 Love ✍️ I got their autograph in person

＋ Follow

When We First Met autographs on eBay

5 listings from 2 sellers · from $50.99

🔔 Alert me to new listings See all 5 →

Adam Devine ‘When We First Met’ Signed Autograph 8x10 Photo ‘Noah’ ACOA Netflix $50.99

ADAM DEVINE SIGNED 'WHEN WE FIRST MET' 8x10 MOVIE PHOTO BECKETT BAS COA $76.49

eBay links on this site may result in RACC earning a commission through eBay Partner Network.

Cast

23 cast members on RACC · 3 met in person by collectors

Adam DeVine Noah Ashby 77 for sale

Alexandra Daddario Avery Martin 3 for saleMet by 6

Shelley Hennig Carrie Grey Met by 1 Andrew Bachelor Max

Robbie Amell Ethan 107 for saleMet by 3 Dean J. West Phil

Tony Cavalero Angus Young 36 for sale

Delfeayo Marsalis Danny Daryn Kahn Drunk Hulk Peter Jaymes Jr. Chad Martin Bats Bradford Devon

Noureen DeWulf Margo Chelsea Bruland Mary Adam Henslee Amos Tenea Intriago Rebecca Kyler Porche Trevor Bertha Bindewald Marta Talbott Lin Mr. Chun Audrey Bishop Mrs. Martin Bill Rainey Mr. Martin Bryan Hall Barista (uncredited) 3 for sale

Chris Wylde Mr. Costigan 4 for sale Michael Scott Garçonne 13 for sale

Show all 23

Someone missing, or listed by mistake? Tell us →

Graphmasters

Who met the cast of When We First Met

Graphmasters tracks autographs collectors got in person, never purchases.

What’s Graphmasters?

9collectors met a cast member in person

3 of 23cast met so far

Oct 2026most recent meet

On lists: Baywatch — Cast Carry-On — Cast Cheaper by the Dozen 2 — Cast Code 8 — Cast Ghosts of Girlfriends Past — Cast Green Book — Cast

Most cast met

Lauren Townsend Shelley Hennig, Robbie Amell 2 of 23 cast 2

Dominic Manning ✓ Trusted Alexandra Daddario 1 of 23 cast 3

Giovanni Camino Alexandra Daddario 1 of 23 cast 4

Steve Fernandez ✓ Trusted Robbie Amell 1 of 23 cast 5

Dan Page Alexandra Daddario 1 of 23 cast 6

Billy Lomas ✓ Trusted Alexandra Daddario 1 of 23 cast 7

Alexandre Nihous ✓ Trusted Alexandra Daddario 1 of 23 cast 8

Xavier Pelletier ✓ Trusted Alexandra Daddario 1 of 23 cast 9

Brad Sanguin ✓ Trusted Robbie Amell 1 of 23 cast

Met one of the cast in person? Tick the ones whose autograph you got.In-person autographs only, never purchases.

✍️ I got their autograph in person See the cast

ISO
Nobody has an ISO for When We First Met yet. Be the first.

What’s an ISO?

ISO means in search of. You post the autograph you want (who, what item, your budget), and sellers who can get it, or already have it, reach out to you. It’s free, and it’s how many collectors find pieces that never hit eBay.

In RACC collections

Pieces RACC members have put on show

Add yours →

No member has shown a When We First Met piece yet. Add yours.

No When We First Met drops yet. Be first to know when there is one. Drops are official signed merchandise that artists, record labels and official distributors release regularly, and they sell out fast.

Alerts come as a daily email digest and a bell on RACC.

🔔 Sign in for alerts

Questions? Message RACC Team

When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.